Costs, Health & Making the Decision

Choosing where to live as we grow older is both a financial and a personal decision.

Remaining at home, moving to an independent living community, or entering a Continuing Care Retirement Community (CCRC) can each be an excellent choice.

But the best decision depends on more than today's expenses or living arrangements. We also need to consider what happens if our health changes, we lose the ability to drive, or we need substantial assistance.

Comparing the Costs

At first glance, remaining in your own home may seem considerably less expensive than moving to a retirement community.

For someone who owns a mortgage-free house and needs little assistance, that may well be true.

However, a meaningful comparison should include all the expenses associated with each option.

Staying in Your Own Home

Costs may include:

A particularly important consideration is the potential cost of home care.

Someone who needs assistance for only a few hours each week may find remaining at home quite affordable. But daily assistance, overnight supervision, or round-the-clock care can become extremely expensive.

Independent Living Communities

Monthly fees often include some combination of housing, maintenance, meals, activities, and transportation.

The financial advantage is greater predictability for many everyday expenses, although monthly fees can increase and some services cost extra.

However, most independent living communities do not include substantial personal care or nursing services.

If additional care becomes necessary, residents may face significant new expenses or need to move elsewhere.

Continuing Care Retirement Communities

Many CCRCs require both an entrance fee and monthly payments.

The entrance fee may be substantial, but some contracts provide financial protection against the potentially high costs of assisted living or nursing care.

Other contracts require residents to pay separately for these services.

Two CCRCs with similar entrance fees and monthly charges may offer very different financial protections.

Some entrance fees are partially refundable to residents or their estates, but the conditions and timing of refunds vary.

Don't Forget the Value of Your Home

For homeowners, selling a house may release substantial equity that can help finance a move.

However, the comparison should also consider the investment returns or appreciation that might be forgone by using those proceeds for an entrance fee.

A refundable entrance fee is not equivalent to money in a readily accessible investment account.

Taxes, insurance, inflation, investment income, and potential healthcare expenses all affect the calculation.

Rather than comparing only current monthly expenses, it may be more useful to estimate total costs over five, ten, or fifteen years under several possible health scenarios.

Health, Longevity, and Social Connections

Where we live can influence how active, socially connected, and mentally engaged we remain.

Research has linked loneliness and social isolation with increased risks of depression, cardiovascular disease, cognitive decline, and premature mortality.

However, these associations do not prove that moving to a retirement community will improve health or extend life.

Some people maintain active, socially connected lives in their own homes. Others find that retirement communities make participation much easier.

Physical Activity

Regular exercise is particularly important for older adults.

Walking, strength training, balance exercises, and other activities help preserve mobility and independence.

A community with convenient exercise facilities and organized programs may encourage participation.

But a person who already walks regularly, exercises, and enjoys outdoor activities at home may have little to gain in this respect.

Social Engagement

Shared meals, lectures, concerts, discussion groups, volunteering, and other activities can make it easier to develop friendships.

For someone who has lost a spouse, stopped driving, or become socially isolated, these opportunities may be especially valuable.

Still, living near other people does not automatically prevent loneliness. The quality of relationships matters more than the number of activities offered.

Cognitive Health

Physical activity, social engagement, and management of cardiovascular risk factors are associated with better cognitive health.

A retirement community may make some of these activities easier to pursue, but there is not strong evidence that moving into one, by itself, prevents Alzheimer's disease.

The important issue is whether the living environment helps a person maintain healthy habits and meaningful relationships.

Special Considerations for Couples

For couples, the decision may become complicated when one spouse develops health problems.

At home, the healthier spouse may gradually become the primary caregiver. This can create physical, emotional, and financial strain.

In a CCRC, one spouse may be able to receive assisted living or nursing care while the other remains in independent living.

This arrangement can make visiting easier and may reduce some caregiving responsibilities.

However, couples should investigate whether additional fees apply when spouses live at different levels of care.

They should also ask what happens financially after one spouse dies.

Living Alone or Without Family Support

For someone living alone, or for a couple without nearby relatives, future support deserves special attention.

Family members often help with transportation, medical appointments, emergencies, financial decisions, and arranging care.

Without that assistance, remaining at home may become more complicated as health needs increase.

A well-managed retirement community can provide social opportunities, emergency assistance, and access to services.

But even a CCRC may not provide someone to act as a personal advocate or make important medical and financial decisions.

People without available family support should consider establishing a healthcare proxy, durable power of attorney, emergency contacts, and, when appropriate, arrangements with a professional care manager or fiduciary.

The important question is not simply who will provide care, but who will help make sure the right care is provided.

When Is the Right Time to Move?

One of the most difficult questions is whether to move while still healthy or wait until assistance becomes necessary.

Moving earlier has several potential advantages.

It may be easier to adjust to new surroundings, develop friendships, participate in activities, and become familiar with the community.

Some CCRCs also have health and independence requirements for admission.

Waiting can make sense when someone is happy at home, has a strong support network, and can comfortably manage everyday responsibilities.

But waiting until a medical crisis occurs may limit the available choices.

A useful principle is to investigate the alternatives before you urgently need them.

Visiting communities does not obligate you to move. It simply gives you information that may become valuable later.

CCRC Waiting Lists: Why Planning Early Matters

Some popular Continuing Care Retirement Communities have waiting lists that extend for several years, particularly for desirable apartment sizes or locations.

Getting on a waiting list early can be a smart decision, even if you are not ready to move.

Many CCRCs allow prospective residents to join a waiting list by paying a deposit. In some communities, when an apartment becomes available, you can decline the opportunity and remain on the list without losing your position. However, policies vary, and some communities limit how often you can decline.

This flexibility can be valuable. You may be perfectly happy in your present home but want the option of moving several years later.

Before joining a waiting list, ask:

The important lesson is that joining a waiting list and deciding to move are often two separate decisions.

For someone considering a CCRC, investigating communities and joining a waiting list in their 70s may preserve options that could become much more valuable in their 80s.

Questions to Ask Before Deciding

Whether considering independent living or a CCRC, prospective residents should investigate several issues.

Lifestyle and community

Healthcare and assistance

Financial considerations

Family and future planning

Making the Decision

There is no universally best place to grow older.

For some people, remaining at home provides the greatest happiness, independence, and financial flexibility.

For others, independent living offers an appealing combination of convenience, companionship, and freedom from household responsibilities.

A CCRC may be especially attractive to people who want to plan for future healthcare needs while enjoying an active retirement lifestyle.

The decision should reflect personal priorities, financial resources, health, relationships, and willingness to accept uncertainty.

Perhaps the most useful question is this:

"Which living arrangement is most likely to help me remain healthy, independent, socially connected, and secure—not just today, but in the years ahead?"

There may be no perfect answer. But understanding the choices before a crisis occurs can make an enormous difference.

← Previous: Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs)      Next: Living Alone After 75 →